Nibby Priest, CIC, Principal Agent-President-Owner
Nibby Priest began his insurance career in August 1983, working in his father’s business while attending Henderson Community College. In the fall of 1984, he transferred to Eastern Kentucky University, where he continued his studies. Nibby graduated from EKU in the spring of 1986 with a Bachelor of Business Administration degree in Insurance.
While at EKU, he became a member of Gamma Iota Sigma, the honorary insurance fraternity. In May 1986, he returned to the family business. On July 1, 1989, Nibby purchased an interest in The Computery of Henderson, Inc., a computer consulting company. He balanced roles in both the insurance and computer industries until the spring of 1993, when he sold his stake in The Computery.
In 2020, Nibby earned his Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) professional designation, completing the rigorous coursework in less than one year—a testament to his dedication to professional growth.
In 2024, Nibby celebrated 40 years in the insurance industry, marking a significant milestone in his professional journey.
Nibby is nationally recognized for his expertise in insurance agency automation consulting, working with Vertafore and the National Users of AGENA Systems. He has also served as a part-time instructor at Henderson Community College, teaching a variety of computer-related courses.
Throughout his life, Nibby has been active in numerous boards and organizations in Henderson. He currently serves as Commissioner-Chairperson for the Housing Authority of Henderson and as Trustee-Treasurer for the Henderson County Public Library.
Since 2011, Nibby has volunteered with the Henderson VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) program, serving as the local coordinator. In recent years, this initiative—with the help of 26 other volunteers—has assisted over 2,200 individuals in preparing and electronically filing their tax returns with federal and state authorities, resulting in over $2.5 million in tax refunds for the community. Nibby takes great pride in this vital volunteer effort.
Nibby is the local (Henderson, KY) AARP Driver Safety Instructor, a role he has held since 2016. He has helped more than 800 people complete the AARP Driver Safety Course in Henderson. He typically offers classes in the spring and fall each year and is available to teach in other areas as well.
James T. Roll, CIC, Licensed Insurance Professional
James is a lifelong member of the Henderson community. He began his insurance career in April 1994 with American General Life & Accident as a sales agent and was promoted to sales manager within a year. In January 1997, James joined our agency, focusing primarily on Personal Lines accounts. Over time, his role expanded, and he now also assists with Commercial Lines accounts. In May 2010, James earned his Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation, further strengthening his expertise and commitment to professional excellence.
James is an active member of Jerusalem Masonic Lodge # 9 under the Grand Lodge of Kentucky, where he has served as Past Master and currently holds the position of Secretary. The Lodge is deeply committed to serving those in need. Through various fundraising efforts, members have supported organizations such as St. Anthony’s Hospice, Riverview School, Women & Children’s Shelter, and the Children’s Advocacy Center. The Lodge is currently delivering two bicycles to every public school in Henderson County to promote perfect attendance and the importance of education, and it also provides scholarships to students in the nursing program at Henderson Community College.
In addition to his Masonic service, James previously served as Treasurer of the Smith Mills Volunteer Fire Department. Following its 2025 merger with the Corydon Civil Defense Fire Department, James now serves as Treasurer and a board member of the newly combined department.
Outside of work and volunteer commitments, James discovered a new passion on January 1, 2025. After finding relatives’ headstones in need of care, he began cleaning and repairing them to restore dignity and visibility to their final resting places. What started as a personal project has grown into a community effort, with several volunteers now assisting. James enthusiastically shares this passion with others, encouraging families to honor and care for their loved ones’ memorials.
Terri Knight, CISR, Licensed Insurance Professional
Terri has been employed by the Vaughn Agency since May 1979. She graduated from the Office Administration program at Henderson Community College. In April 1985, she obtained her Property and Casualty Insurance license. Terri earned the Accredited Customer Service Representative (ACSR) designation in May 1991 and is recognized by the Independent Insurance Agents of America. Additionally, she received her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation in May 2010. In 2019, Terri celebrated 40 years of working in the insurance industry.
Gina began working at Vaughn Insurance Agency in February 1995. In February 1998, she earned her ACSR certification, and in May 1998, she obtained her property and casualty insurance license.
Kally Priest Clayton, Licensed Insurance Professional | Agent
Kally joined Vaughn Insurance Agency in September 2023. She is licensed in Life and Health Insurance in both Indiana and Kentucky. Kally supports her uncle, Nibby Priest, in serving Health and Medicare clients and is actively expanding her expertise across all areas of operating an independent insurance agency.
